…they’re very pretty and cool, but…
I’m starting to see and hear the type of real reviews of the [[[iPhone]]] that I was hoping would emerge. Dave Winer’s is great: iPhone, month 1 (Scripting News). It confirms many of my assumptions about living with an iPhone.
If I were looking for a new iPod and mobile video device, the iPhone would be cool (albeit overpriced). As a cellphone, the fact that it is locked to Cingular / the new AT&T is a huge minus in my book (as a former Cingular customer who was never overly satisfied with anything they offered). The lack of 3G connectivity is absolutely mind-boggling to me. Why would you offer a device that is primarily amazing as a revolutionary web device, but offer no really strong mobile connectivity? I mean, if I’m near a Wi-Fi connection, I’m usually near my laptop or desktop computer. When I would need the iPhone to be great is when I’m not near that access. From what I’ve seen, in those situations, the EDGE connectivity on the iPhone is much too slow when compared to my Helio. Sure, the Helio Ocean doesn’t offer the full-mobile web, but when you’re mobile, it’s the information that matters more than the appearance, and the Helio gets that information to me much faster than the iPhone.
That being said, I think Conrad Quilty-Harper is correct in saying that the Google Maps is the “killer app” of the iPhone. Of course, the iPhone doesn’t have GPS so you have to know where you are when you use it, but thanks to no need to access the GPS, it loads fast, quickly serves up maps of locations, and quickly offers phone numbers.
That’s great, but I’ll stick with GOOGLE411 on my Helio.
I hope iPhone 2.0 has more to offer. I also hope we see it sooner than we would normally see an Apple product line refresh. This is the mobile market, so hopefully it will come out faster than normal. When it does, I hope it’s divorced from Cingular and that there is an actual chat client of some sort. SMS-only is a crap decision that was most likely pushed for by the new AT&T trying to screw everyone out of more money for mobile data transfer.
Also, has anyone blogged from their iPhone yet? Apple, if you want to make a truly revolutionary iPhone 2.0, make it work seamlessly with all the major blogging platforms, integrate the camera with uploading to sites like Flickr, let it record video that can upload straight to YouTube, give it full copy and paste capabilities and tabbed browsing. Make it where we can switch between these different applications without shutting any of them down, just like we can on our computers running OS X. If the “running OS X” iPhone had all that, it would be the true mobile communications device of the Internet community and everyone else, because it would further enable our conversations rather than simply be the hot new gadget we’re all talking about. If it becomes part of the mechanics of the conversation itself, then there’s little worry about what happens when the next big gadget comes around.