The full title of this old paper of mine is God, John[ny], and The Wandering Jew Are Americans: Manifestations of Biblical Legends/Myths of Immortality Within Late 20th Century Popular Culture. You can find it here in html format, and here as a PDF. It is copyright to myself, but I freely grant anyone the privilege to use the text in a classroom or educational setting, as long as it is not for a publication or for profit.
To the person who wrote to me several months ago, asking that I repost this article online, my apologies for the long delay. It took me quite a while to track the paper down.
Update: Found the song and video the paper is partially about on YouTube:
UPDATE AGAIN: Playing around with Issuu and I decided to embed the paper here: